March 1st, 2012 / 5 Comments


Oh I know there are going to be people out there saying, how come you only post the positive reviews and not the negative.  And my response is – I’m a glass half full kinda gal.  I’m not really interested in the negative ones because unless they are constructive criticism, what’s the point in sharing, all it manages to do is irritate the hell out of me because sometimes people just don’t want to stray from the herd of haters.  Anyway I digress.  Michael Coveney of WhatsOnStage gives us his honest review of Bel Ami and I like it:

“Cheek by Jowl directors Declan Donnellan and Nick Ormerod hosted a screening of their new, and indeed first, movie in the Charlotte Street Hotel yesterday afternoon.

Bel Ami is a sumptuous transposition to the screen (by no means the first) of Guy de Maupassant’s fin de siecle Parisian novel starring Robert Pattinson as Georges Duroy, the dissolute French soldier who rises to the top of society and journalism by the simple expedient of sleeping with the wives of his employers.

These three married lovers are played by Uma Thurman, sly, slinky and smouldering as the political editor’s wife, who writes Georges’ articles for him; Kristin Scott Thomas, giving a brilliant performance of vulnerability thawing into hysterical abandon as the editor’s wife, whom he seduces in church and viciously rejects partly in order to marry her daughter; and Christina Ricci, foxy and flirtatious as the deeply attractive Clotilde, whom he loves above all the others, and whose pert little daughter dubs him “bel ami.”

It’s a deeply sour tale of having your cake and eating it, and it’s beautifully played and sumptuously costumed. And you can’t fail to notice in these rocky days for newspaper ethics, that Georges moves sideways from his diary of a cavalryman in the Algerian war to head of gossip on the broadsheet; he draws a line, though, at taking his share of the profits when war-mongering becomes a sort of insider trading.

Donnellan and Ormerod ran a five-week rehearsal period before they even got on the studio floor, and it shows. The music swells, but not all the time; you can hear the actors breathe, the long dresses rustle, the symbolic cockroach scuttle across Georges’ attic before he pummels it to death.

As a debut movie, and made for the comparative pittance of nine million euros, it’s almost indecently good and highly accomplished. And although Pattinson twitches his nostrils a little too often, he’s spot on as the louche lothario.

The set-piece scenes, too, in low taverns and high society, are a vigorous swirl of colour and choreography, studded with sharp performances all round. Nice to see little nuggety vignettes from Timothy Walker (an early Cheek by Jowl stalwart) as a lawyer and Christopher Fulford as a police officer.

There’s a magnificent deathbed scene when Georges goes to comfort Uma Thurman’s almost-widow as Philip Glenister coughs up his last on the coast at Cannes. And the interiors and location shots (Budapest stands in for Paris) are a continuous delight.”

If you want to read the full article, click on hyperlink above.

Thanks to BelAmiFilm for the tip.

  • Jules
    Posted on March 01, 2012

    Brilliant!! Thanks Maria – I’m a glass half full kinda gal myself. 😉 This was an enjoyable read.

    A twitching nostril can be very attractive – just saying. 😉

  • Sue
    Posted on March 01, 2012

    haha Jules ….”a twitching nostril” ~ who’d have thought?!

    Thanks Maria ~ I’m more than happy that you’re selective with the reviews you post ~ this IS our ‘happiest place on earth ‘ after all!

  • Vicky
    Posted on March 01, 2012

    What a great review!!! Had a little chuckle at the “twitching nostrils” comment, didn’t realize that was a bad thing. LOL Jules, i hear you on that one!! Thanks Maria and please feel free to keep seeing that glass half full!!!

  • Cindy
    Posted on March 01, 2012

    I could watch Rob and his “twitching nostrils” all day thanks very much! Great review Thanks ox

  • Val
    Posted on March 02, 2012

    🙂 Spot on, @Sue. Thanks Maria, love the way you do things, please don’t ever change! And why shouldn’t such a fine looking nose perform to the very best of it’s capabilities? Not all noses are so talented.

  • Leave a Reply

    Current Mood
    image host
    Rob’s Promo Schedule
    image host
  • Rob’s Film Schedule
    The Batman Role: Bruce Wayne | Batman
    Director: Matt Reeves
    Release Date: 4 March 2022. Filming commenced 27 Jan 2020 | Filming recommenced 17 September 2020. Check out our film page for updated release dates by clicking "News" below.

    Tenet Role: Neil
    Director: Christopher Nolan
    Release Date: 26 August 2020 - check out our film page for all upcoming theatrical and DVD release dates by clicking on "News" below

    Waiting for the Barbarians Role: Warrant Officer Mandel
    Director: Ciro Guerra
    Release Date: Australia on Digital & DVD 7 October 2020. To find other release dates head over to our dedicated film page by clicking on "News" below.

    The Devil All the Time Role: Preston Teagardin
    Director: Antonio Campos
    Release Date: 16 September 2020 - currently screening on Netflix

    The Stars at Noon Role: Unamed Englishman
    Director: Claire Denis
    Release Date: 2021 possibly 2022 due to COVID-19. Pre-Production: 18 February 2020 (Filming rumoured April 2021 but looks like will be delayed due to Claire working on another project).

    The Lighthouse Role: Ephraim Winslow
    Director: Robert Eggers
    DVD releases at Film Page - click News below

    The King Role: The Dauphin of France
    Director: David Michôd
    Release Date: World Premiere (Out of Competition) Venice Film Festival 2019 2 Sept 2019 | Still available on Netflix.

    Information for all of Robert's past films can also be found at RPAU's individual film pages by clicking photo below.
    RPAU Exclusives
    RPAU's Exclusive Interview with Robert Pattinson on the Red Carpet at The Rover Premiere Sydney Film Festival 2014.

    Robert Pattinson and David Michôd respond to RPAU's Question at the Official Sydney Press Conference for The Rover June 2014.

    Other interviews with RPAU on the Red Carpet at The Rover Premiere Sydney Film Festival 2014 can be found at The Rover Master Post.
    RPAustralia Twitter
    RPAustralia Calendar

    Free Download 2021 RPAU Calendar

    image host
    Thanks to Suze
    Rob’s Fanmail Address
    UK Address
    Robert Pattinson
    c/o Curtis Brown Group Ltd.
    Haymarket House
    5th Floor, 28-29
    Haymarket London, SW1Y 4SP

    US Address
    Robert Pattinson
    c/o William Morris Endeavor (WME) Entertainment
    Stephanie Ritz
    9601 Wilshire Blvd. Floor 3
    Beverly Hills, CA 90210
    Site Meter
    Rob Fans Online: 616,237
    Total Views: 7,367,734
    About Us
  • Site Opened: 4 November 2008
  • Email Us: (for tips & suggestions) &
  • Hosted by: Dreamhost
  • Designed by:

  • Follow us on Twitter

    Robert Pattinson Australia is not affiliated with Robert Pattinson or his management in any way. Any form of copyright infringement is unintended. We respect Robert's right to privacy and do not post intrusive photos or information about his private life. Respecting Robert because actions speak louder than words.